Season 1: First Show-July 27, 1979 - Last of the Red Hot Lovers at the Hilton Hotel as part of the RiverCade celebration
Season 2: 1980-1981
The Valentine Show/ The Diary of Adam & Eve (from the musical “The Apple Tree”)
The Gingerbread Lady
You’re a Good Man Charlie Brown
The Odd Couple
Same Time Next Year
Season 3: 1981-1982
Veronica’s Room
Side by Side by Sondheim
I Oughta Be In Pictures
Season 4: 1982-1983
Who’s On First
Squabbles
I Do! I Do!
Plaza Suite
Season 5: 1983-1984
By Strouse
The Lion in Winter
Godspell
Season 6: 1984-1985
The Murder Room
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
NOTE: November 1986--Moved to the Webster School location, 417 Market Street
Season 7: 1987
The Foreigner
Baby
Deathtrap
Season 8: 1987-1988
Star Spangled Girl
Camelot
Accommodations
Little Shop of Horrors
Brighton Beach Memoirs
Greater Tuna
Season 9: 1988-1989
The Nerd
Hello, Dolly
Crimes of the Heart
The Boy Who Talked To Whales (Hot Dog Theatre)
I Do! I Do!
Footlight Frenzy
The Arkansaw Bear (Hot Dog Theatre)
Season 10: 1989-1990
Side By Side By Sondheim
Anything Goes
I’m Not Rappaport
Man of La Mancha
The Odd Couple (Female Version)
Season 11: 1990-1991
Nunsense
Androcles and the Lion (Hot Dog Theatre)
Broken Hearts (Hot Dog Theatre)
The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas
Broadway Bound
They’re Playing Our Song
Run For Your Wife
Fabulous Fable Factory (Hot Dog Theatre)
Same Time Next Year
Season 12: 1991-1992
Company
Guys and Dolls
Accomplice
Evita
Arsenic and Old Lace
Nunsense
The Near-Sighted Knight and the Far-Sighted Dragon (Hot Dog Theatre)
Season 13: 1992-1993
Lend Me A Tenor
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
The Cemetery Club
Sweeney Todd
Romance/Romance
The Boy Who Stole the Stars (Hot Dog Theatre)
Season 14: 1993-1994
Noises Off
Fiddler on the Roof
I Hate Hamlet
Pump Boys and Dinettes
On Golden Pond
The Magician’s Nephew (Hot Dog Theatre)
Season 15: 1994-1995
It Runs in the Family
A Christmas Carol
The Boys Next Door
The Secret Garden
Nunsense II
Wiley and the Hairy Man (Hot Dog Theatre)
Season 16: 1995-1996
Steel Magnolias
Annie
The Glass Menagerie
Mame
Breaking Legs
Charlotte’s Web (Hot Dog Theatre)
Season 17: 1996-1997
Don’t Dress for Dinner
Phantom
The Diary of Anne Frank
The Music Man
Driving Miss Daisy
Little Luncheonette of Terror (Hot Dog Theatre)
Season 18: 1997-1998
Funny Money
How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
Agnes of God
La Cage Aux Folles
Blithe Spirit
Androcles and the Lion (Hot Dog Theatre)
Season 19: 1998-1999
Moon Over Buffalo
Nunsense Jamboree
The Lion in Winter
The Sound of Music
The Odd Couple
The Brave Little Tailor (Hot Dog Theatre)
Season 20: 1999-2000
The Foreigner
Man of La Mancha
Taking Sides
Children of Eden
The Last Night of Ballyhoo
The Three Little Pigs (Hot Dog Theatre)
How I Learned to Drive (Black Sheep production)
Season 21: 2000-2001
Out of Order or “Whose Wife is it Anyway?”
Nuncrackers
Communicating Doors
Hello Dolly
Over the River and Through the Woods
Little Red Riding Hood (Hot Dog Theatre)
Bash (Black Sheep Production)
Season 22: 2001-2002
Move Over, Mrs. Markham
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
Postmortem
Hotel d’Amour
Last of the Red Hot Lovers
Music Man Jr (Lamb School Production)
The Princess and the Pea (Hot Dog Theatre)
Goldilocks and the Three Bears (Hot Dog Theatre)
Jeffrey (Black Sheep production)
Season 23: 2002-2003
Five Women Wearing the Same Dress
Nunsense, A-Men
Schoolhouse Rock Jr (Lamb School Production)
Lost in Yonkers
Jekyll & Hyde
Lend Me a Tenor
Annie Jr (Lamb School Production)
Cinderella (Hot Dog Theatre)
The Laramie Project (Black Sheep production)
Season 24: 2003-2004
Run for Your Wife
Caught in the Net
Almighty Bob
The Stories of Scheherazade (Lamb School Production)
Titanic
Forever Plaid
Wonderland (Lamb School Production)
Beauty and the Beast (Hot Dog Theatre)
The Play About the Baby (Black Sheep production)
Season 25: 2004-2005
I love You, You’re Perfect, Now Change
Messhuggah-Nuns the Ecumenical Nunsense Musical
The Drawer Boy
Gypsy
Shady Business
The Lady Pirates of Captain Bree (Lamb School Production)
(The True Story of) The Tortoise & The Hare (Hot Dog Theatre)
Whose Life Is It Anyway (Black Sheep Production)
Season 26: 2005-2006
Claptrap
Oleanna (Box show)
Honk!
The Santaland Diaries (Box Show)
Dear Edwina Jr (Lamb School Production)
Misery
Frozen (Box Show)
Godspell
Disney’s Cinderella Kids (Lamb School Production)
Brighton Beach Memoirs
Aladdin Jr (Lamb School Production)
Jack and the Beanstalk (Hot Dog Theatre)
Season 27: 2006-2007
The Sunshine boys
A Christmas Carol the Musical
The Diary of Anne Frank
You’re a Good Man Charlie Brown (revised)
Thrill Me (Box Show)
Tuesdays With Morrie
High School Musical
Season 28: 2007-2008
Almost Maine
The Wizard of Oz
The Effect of Gamma Rays on Man-in-The-Moon Marigolds
Disney’s Sleeping Beauty Kids (Lamb School Production)
Urinetown
Androcles and the Lion (Lamb School Production)
Unnecessary Farce
High School Musical On Stage! (Lamb School Production)
Season 29: 2008-2009
Ashes, Ashes, We All Fall Down (Black Sheep Production)
Leaving Iowa
Frame 312
The Andrews Brothers
Doubt
Big River
Panic
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat (Hot Dog Theatre)
Season 30: 2009-2010
Driving Miss Daisy
Mid-Life The Crisis Musical
Rugrats (Hot Dog Theatre)
Eve’s Odds (Young People’s Theatre)
Our Town
A Year With Frog and Toad (Young People’s Theatre)
Little Women the Musical
Schoolhouse Rock LIVE Jr (Young People’s Theatre)
Don’t Dress for Dinner
Les Miserables school edition (Young People’s Theatre)
Season 31: 2010-2011
The Woman In Black
Gutenberg! The Musical (Young People’s Theatre) (Box Show)
Nuncrackers: The Nunsense Christmas Musical
American Buffalo (Box Show)
Dear Edwina Jr (Young People’s Theatre)
Comedy of Errors (Young People’s Theatre)
Working
‘Night, Mother
The 39 Steps
All Shook Up (Young People’s Theatre)
Season 32: 2011-2012
Yankee Tavern
Columbinus (Young People’s Theatre)
Married Alive
The Musical Adventures of Flat Stanley Jr (Young People’s Theatre)
The MOMologues (Box Show)
Cabaret
Disney’s Cinderella Kids (Young People’s Theatre)
Circle Mirror Transformation (Box Show)
Leading Ladies
Seussical the Musical (Young People’s Theatre)
Season 33: 2012-2013
The Pillowman
Murder at Cafe Noir (fundraiser at Pierce St Mansion) (no playbill, source SCJ)
Anne Frank & Me (Young People’s Theatre)
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr (Young People’s Theatre)
Red (Box Show)
Love, Loss & What I Wore (Box Show)
Vanities
Disney’s Winnie The Pooh Kids (Young People’s Theatre)
Les Miserables
Disney’s Camp Rock (Young People’s Theatre)
Season 34: 2013-2014
Bark! the Musical
Disney’s The Aristocats Kids (Young People’s Theatre)
Flames (Box Show) (World Premiere)
Altar Boyz
Annie Jr (Young People’s Theatre)
33 Variations
Motherhood Out Loud
Making God Laugh
X-Stacy (Box Show)
Once on This Island
Season 35: 2014-2015
The Fox on the Fairway
Hello Herman (Box Show)
Rent
Disney’s Sleeping Beauty Kids (Young People’s Theatre)
Hansel & Gretel and the LONG Way Home (Lamb Caravan)
Necessary Targets (Box Show)
Disney’s My Son Pinocchio Jr (Young People’s Theatre)
Inherit the Wind
Love, Loss & What I Wore
Vanya & Sonia & Masha & Spike
The Marvelous Wonderettes
Season 36: 2015-2016
Monster Makers
Nightfall with Edgar Allan Poe (Young People’s Theatre)
They Called her Beautiful
Fiddler on the Roof Jr (Young People’s Theatre)
Love Letters
The Tin Woman
Miss Abigail’s Guide to Dating Mating & Marriage (Box Show)
Metamorphoses
The Marvelous Wonderettes: Caps & Gowns
Season 37: 2016-2017
Feathers & Teeth
A Midsummer Night’s Dream (Young People’s Theatre)
Peter and the Star Catcher
The Jungle Book (Young People’s Theatre)
A Body of Water (Box Show)
Death of a Salesman
Hoodie (Young People’s Theatre)
Momologues 2: Off to School (Box Show)
On Golden Pond
Pippin
Season 38: 2017-2018
Alabama Story
12th Night (Young People’s Theatre)
James and the Giant Peach
What If (Young People’s Theatre)
The Vagina Monologues (Box Show)
The Crucible
Aura (Box Show)
Steel Magnolias
Snapshots
Season 39: 2018-2019
Now and Then
Back Cover (Box Show)
Mamma Mia
Disney’s Aladdin Jr (Young People’s Theatre)
Church & State
Small Jokes About Monsters (Box Show)
Boeing Boeing
Pageant
Season 40: 2019-2020
Miracle on S. Division St.
Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet (Young People’s Theatre)
Roald Dahl’s Matilda, the Musical
We Are Monsters (Young People’s Theatre)
MOMologues 3: The Final Push (Box Show)
NOTE: In Spring 2020, COVID-19 concerns changed how Lamb produced theatre, forcing shows to be produced only online:
The Show Must Go Online (Young People’s Theatre)
Couples: A Virtual Play
Pandemic Fairy Tale Playlets (video competition)
Playwrighting contest
Monologue Madness
Season 41: 2020-2021
NOTE: During COVID, these fully staged productions were presented to properly distanced, masked, live audiences, and also videostreamed to an online audience:
Outside Mullingar
God’s Favorite
Hate Mail
Bakersfield Mist
Last Five Years
Season 42: 2021-2022
Unnecessary Farce
Winter Wonderettes
The Glass Menagerie
The Memory Show
William Shakespeare’s Long Lost First Play
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
Season 43: 2022-2023
Hollywood, Nebraska
Twelfth Night (Youth Theatre Production)
Another Night Before Christmas
Space Piractes (Youth Theatre Production)
Straight White Men (Staged reading)
The Messenger
Accidentally Brave (Box)
God of Carnage
Disaster! The Musical
Season 44: 2023-2024
A Trick of the Light
Anne Frank & Me (Youth Theatre Production)
The Mousetrap
Tut-Tut (Youth Theatre Production)
The Courtroom (Box)
The Outsider (first production at Morningside University)
Gruesome Playground Injuries (Box)
Tracy Jones
Godspell